For the most up-to-date collection of evidence in my case, demonstrating these accusations are indeed false, now see my summary and links to evidence and court documents.
-:-
The allegations that have been made against me are substantially false. Phase one of my legal action on that will be completed tomorrow. And I will publish those details by the end of this week. But before doing that, I need to address something I consider more important. I know that I’ve made mistakes, which I’ve spoken about openly before, and I want to make clear I’m deeply sorry for having made any women in our community uncomfortable. I also need to make my standards of conduct at future events in the secular community clear, to ensure everyone can feel comfortable with my presence going forward.
This article will cover those two points.
My Apology
I recognize that some of my actions have contributed to this situation. I have not always been as wise or sensitive to context when I ask or approach someone as I should have been. And I have sometimes been too assertive. That has meant that my actions have made some women in our community uncomfortable. That is the furthest thing from what I want for our community, and for that I am very sorry.
I am not guilty of pursuing anyone after being told no. Nor have I touched anyone inappropriately. Nor have I harassed anyone. Nor have I done anything worse than what I already wrote about a year ago. But I want to acknowledge again that I have asked women out in situations where I was not as sensitive to the context or power dynamic as I should have been. In that way, my behavior was contributing to a long-standing climate in which women, especially younger women, may have felt that their value in this community is related to their sexual desirability rather than their activism or intellect. That is the exact opposite of what I want for our community.
I recognize that my role as a speaker and leader in this community requires me to hold myself to a higher standard than I would expect of a regular community member, and that in the past I haven’t always met that standard. To remedy that I will implement the following step to ensure my standards of behavior will meet a higher bar. I also intend to continue listening to and participating in the ongoing community dialog about sexual ethics and leadership standards to continue improving myself.
My New Conduct Standard
I also recognize that the current allegations against me, although largely false, would give event and group leaders pause when considering inviting me to speak or attend. So I want to lay out very clearly what anyone inviting me to an event, or encountering me at one, can expect from me from here on. I want to be clear that I’m not suggesting that this is how everyone, or even all speakers, should behave at events. This is the standard that I am adopting for my own behavior in recognition that I have not been as well calibrated on this as I believed I was in the past, and in recognition that I have to restore trust by being more circumspect than I would expect of others if I’m going to be able to continue doing the work I love for a community that I value. I am revising this rule now that my case is settled (which I will also announce here). The rule I observed until then:
- When at any freethought-community event or associated afterparties, whether speaking, tabling, or merely attending, I will not seek or accept a sexual relationship with anyone at them, except those I have an already-established sexual relationship with, or someone who has expressed interest in advance of the event and we’ve already discussed it before I’ve arrived.
The rule I’m observing now:
- When at any freethought-community event or associated afterparties, whether speaking, tabling, or merely attending, I might once and only politely ask after someone’s interest, and only if they have already discussed personal matters with me, and I will only seek or accept a sexual relationship with someone who clearly expresses their interest in it.
Although conferences and events are excellent places to meet fascinating like-minded people, Greta Christina is correct that they aren’t hook-up bars, and I largely agree with what she says in Sex-Positive Does Not Mean Anything Goes. But I can see how some of my past behavior has given the mistaken impression that conquesting is how I pursue women or view events in our community. Because of that, I want to be clear that my motive for being at these events is to advance the goals of the secular movement, including education and morale. That is the work I dedicate myself to. Partners and other friends of mine have in the past told me about various ways they set boundaries to separate their personal lives from their work. Like them I need to do this more than I have been. At events in the freethought community I intend to keep my focus on my work. I will only pursue new relationships at them in clear and exceptional cases.
None of this means that I will stop advocating for acceptance of kink, polyamory, social justice, and sex-positivity. I believe that men and women getting over cultural hangups about sex and sexuality will do a great deal to increase human happiness. I will continue to be transparent about my lifestyle and my values. I will continue to frankly answer questions about sexuality when I’m asked. And I will discuss sexuality openly and publicly in venues specifically designated for that, including my own blog.
My experience with and understanding of sexual ethics is evolving, and I have always admitted when I’ve made mistakes, although none have been as egregious as the allegations against me now. I believe that I have recognized and learned from my mistakes, and I hope for the opportunity to continue to improve as a person and as a member of the secular community. I am wholeheartedly asking the secular community to help me do that.
-:-
German Translation by Fijavan Brenk
I think Richard Carrier does a great job here of both acknowledging fault and describing how he will change his conduct moving forward to rectify the situation. Acknowledging fault and indicating how I intend to rectify my behavior going forward is what I always aim to do when I make mistakes, and I am glad to see him doing the same. I look forward to him becoming a better advocate for the causes I care about in the future. I am happy to be a Patreon supporter to him.
I’m a gay man, but all of these issues exist in the gay world as well as the straight world. I’ve known men who’ve been verifiably sexually assaulted, and I’ve also known two men who suffered from delusions, who (also verifiably) would have sex willingly with other men and then convince themselves that they had been coerced or even forced. They went through life feeling assaulted and leaving a trail of confused men with damaged reputations behind them.
Knowing that both things happen – real assault and post hoc delusions of assault – I’m always supportive of those who report assaults (protect their privacy, respect their distress) while not assuming that I know what’s true until it’s investigated and both sides show their evidence.
I think Richard is doing exactly what needs to be done right now. I’m happy to continue my patreon support while he goes through this, and I think he’s dealt with that well, too. And it’s good to see him teaching a new class, and not being totally consumed by these accusations and their aftermath.
The article above has been translated into German (see Entschuldigung & geht nach vorn) by Fijavan Brenk at Leiden University.
Update: I have added the words “I may revise this rule after my case is settled (which I will also announce here). But until then:” to clarify that things could possibly change in future. But currently they are as stated.
Hi Carrier. I believe you are slowly recovering the trust of secular community. Two years ago you debated with Sargon of Akkad, and when Matt Dillahunty was asked some few years ago in his show about the historicity of Jesus, he said that the person could check your work. I feel your regret is/was true, and that you did something to change (which was this new standard you try to follow). I hope one day your reputation might not be anymore reason for people rejecting you, and while I aknowledge that you did shit (as I don’t wanna blindly defend you), you show that you don’t deserve to be cancelled anymore. Try always to be better, man. Cheers from Brazil. Keep up your work, head up, being respectful, that one day what you did won’t be a shadow anymore.