I’ve been too busy to blog about all the things I wanted to this month. From the Black Lives Matter protest to the Ophelia Benson departure to a weird John Loftus flameout currently going on. So here I’m quickly trying to catch up. Second on deck: the Benson departure…

-:-

2.

Ophelia Benson has left FreethoughtBlogs because of critics expressing suspicion of her being a little too friendly to the ideas of Trans Exclusive Radical Feminism (for reasons best summarized by Stephanie Zvan, though unfortunately without links; though I’ve checked, and the things she says happened, happened—even if you want to quibble about how it’s described).

I care about this issue. I have written on it before. People should get to represent as and be identified as the gender that suits them. And we should work on ourselves at accepting that. In this respect, Benson’s behavior wasn’t evil. But it was suspicious and bizarre. And I think she kept deflecting from the real issues people were raising, dismissing many calm and valid critiques (even the general absence of actual critique) as a witch hunt, rather than seeing that some of them had a point, and that she could do better on this issue, and might want to rethink some of her conclusions and affiliations.

I didn’t raise a voice in this, partly because my voice wasn’t needed (I think Gabriel and Dadhabhoy and Thibeault were doing fine, and I worried a further pile-on might not have been helpful), but mostly because I had just recently transgressed on Benson’s blog on a separate issue, and I worried, given Benson’s suddenly unusually paranoid defensiveness in this case, that she would have made any criticism I voiced about this, about that, thus creating a distraction from what everyone else was already capably saying. But she has left now, so it doesn’t matter.

My take: it really comes down to the fact that Benson refused to say she believed trans women were women, and though she insisted she supported their legal rights, she peculiarly refused to denounce the anti-trans-rights letter sent to the UN by anti-trans activists (which they even followed-up) whom, and whose groups, she kept consulting for advice on the issue (and whom she also refused to disaffiliate from).

On believing someone is a woman when they say they are, this is no different than believing someone is an atheist when they say they are. There are legit questions of what it means to be a woman, but imagine saying, “I support full political rights for blacks, I just can’t say I believe they are the equal of whites,” because that doesn’t sound far different than, “I support full political rights for trans women, I just can’t say I believe they are the equal of cis women.” And Benson never adequately explained why anyone should believe trans women aren’t women. Apart from harboring the thought that they aren’t. And that’s worrying.

The letter she wouldn’t denounce, meanwhile, called for worldwide opposition to trans person rights, especially in respect to the silly matter of bathrooms, essentially declaring trans women to be really men intent on raping women in bathrooms. In other words, a la Trump, they were calling trans women rapists. (They also, a la Trump, added a “maybe some of them are good people” qualification, of course.) And that’s pretty shitty, and very clearly anti-trans. As is their required assumption that trans women are “really” men. Concerns Benson never adequately addressed, but avoided addressing by calling it all a meaningless witch hunt.

No one here called for her to depart. She chose to on her own. We all maintain many disagreements with each other at FreethoughBlogs, and criticize each other often, without this result. It appears Benson didn’t think colleagues should publicly criticize each other, particularly in ways she saw as paranoid for some reason. I hope at least she enjoys less stress in her new home.

Meanwhile, let’s not make things harder for trans persons. Don’t chum around with people who oppose their civil rights. Don’t go asking them for advice. Condemn their efforts to oppose the rights of trans persons. And recognize gender as a felt and performed identity. Because that’s what it is. As I’ve explained before.

-:-

Discover more from Richard Carrier Blogs

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading